Is There Anything Bigger Than the Hercules–Corona Borealis Great Wall?

Discover if anything is bigger than the Hercules–Corona Borealis Great Wall and explore the universe’s confirmed and mysterious mega-structures.

Key Takeaways

• The Hercules–Corona Borealis Great Wall (HCB) is claimed to be the largest structure in the observable universe (~10 billion light-years) — but its reality is highly disputed.
• The Quipu Superstructure (~1.4 billion light-years) is currently the largest confirmed cosmic structure.
• The Giant Arc and Big Ring are two enormous, nearby structures in deep space that challenge the Cosmological Principle and could signal new physics.
• “Bigger” depends on how you define a structure: confirmed cosmic web overdensities vs. putative statistical alignments.
• New telescopes like Euclid and the Vera C. Rubin Observatory may soon settle the debate.

What Is the Hercules–Corona Borealis Great Wall?

Milky Way galaxy, with Earth at the tip, next to a full side view of the galaxy and highlighting the position of the Hercules–Corona Borealis Great Wall.” class=”wp-image-21433″/>

The Hercules–Corona Borealis Great Wall (HCB) is a proposed cosmic superstructure announced in 2013.
Researchers suggested it spans about 10 billion light-years, making it almost 10% of the observable universe’s diameter.

How It Was “Discovered”

• Astronomers used gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) as tracers of distant star-forming galaxies.
• A cluster of 14 GRBs between redshift z = 1.6–2.1 appeared unusually concentrated.
• The team interpreted this as evidence for an enormous structure between the constellations Hercules and Corona Borealis.

The Problem

• GRBs are rare and unevenly detected due to telescope coverage (Swift satellite bias).
• Later studies suggested the clustering might be statistical noise or an observational bias, not a real structure.
• No galaxy surveys have independently confirmed its existence.

Bottom line: The HCB may be the “largest claimed” structure, but it is not the largest confirmed one.

Why “Bigger” Depends on How You Define Structure

When we talk about the largest structure, there are three categories:

1. Confirmed Cosmic Web Overdensities
   • Mapped directly via galaxy redshifts or X-ray galaxy cluster surveys.
   • Example: Quipu Superstructure, Sloan Great Wall.
2. Statistical Alignments (Putative Structures)
   • Inferred from sparse tracers (GRBs, quasars).
   • Example: HCB, Huge-LQG (later debunked).
3. Cosmology-Challenging Anomalies
   • Statistically significant, unusual formations that break theoretical size limits.
   • Example: Giant Arc and Big Ring.

Confirmed Largest Structure in the Universe | Quipu Superstructure

universe with highlighted galaxies and key features.” class=”wp-image-21434″/>

The Quipu Superstructure is the largest reliably characterized cosmic web filament.

• Size: ~1.3–1.4 billion light-years long
• Distance: 425–815 million light-years away
• Detection Method: X-ray mapping of galaxy clusters via the ROSAT satellite
• Why It’s Reliable: Uses direct observation of massive galaxy clusters, not indirect tracers.

This structure’s size pushes up against the “End of Greatness” — the scale (~1.2 billion light-years) where the universe is predicted to become homogeneous.

Giant Arc and Big Ring — The Real Challenge to Cosmology

Two recent discoveries have drawn more attention than even the HCB.

The Giant Arc

• Size: ~3.3 billion light-years
• Detection: Mapping magnesium-II (MgII) absorption lines in quasar light.
• Significance: Far exceeds the theoretical size limit predicted by the Cosmological Principle.

The Big Ring

• Diameter: ~1.3 billion light-years
• Circumference: ~4 billion light-years
• Located in the same region of the sky and similar distance as the Giant Arc.

The odds of finding two massive structures so close together by chance are extremely small. This has led to speculation about new physics, including:

• Cosmic strings from the early universe.
• Conformal Cyclic Cosmology (Roger Penrose).

Other Cosmic Giants Worth Knowing

Why the Cosmological Principle Matters

The Cosmological Principle says that on large enough scales, the universe is:

• Homogeneous (same everywhere)
• Isotropic (same in all directions)

It predicts no coherent structures larger than ~1.2 billion light-years.
If structures like the Giant Arc and Big Ring are real, we may need to revise ΛCDM cosmology — the standard model of the universe.

Firsthand Perspective | My Experience as a Deep-Space Research Writer

space, with star constellations and connecting lines overlaid on the cosmic background, features the vast Hercules–Corona Borealis Great Wall faintly visible in the distance.” class=”wp-image-21435″/>

Over years of covering astronomy, I’ve seen sensational discoveries come and go.
When HCB was first announced, space media exploded with headlines.
But as more critical studies came out, enthusiasm faded — replaced by caution.

I’ve interviewed astrophysicists who told me the same thing:

“Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. Without independent confirmation, the Hercules–Corona Borealis Great Wall is just an intriguing possibility.”

What Future Telescopes Could Reveal

Upcoming surveys will bring clarity:

• Euclid Space Telescope (ESA): Mapping billions of galaxies with high precision.
• Vera C. Rubin Observatory: Deep-sky imaging of the southern hemisphere.
• Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope: Wide-field infrared mapping.

These could:

• Confirm or debunk the HCB.
• Fully map the Giant Arc and Big Ring.
• Discover even larger confirmed structures.

FAQs

References

• NASA Astrophysics Data System
• European Space Agency (ESA) — Euclid mission brief
• Horváth et al. (2013), Astronomy & Astrophysics
• Lopez et al. (2021), Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society

Deep-space research writer & curator of cosmic knowledge.

The Universe Episodes